The Art of Protest
Control vs. chaos, democratic deficits, or why modernity breeds toothless anarchy.
We stumbled across The Art of Protest by filmmaker and illustrator Temujin Doran almost randomly, only to discover a cunning and insightful mini-documentary. The film makes a simple yet powerful cultural observation: Today, protests have become their own ideological antithesis. The meticulous planning, orchestration and coordination are robbing protests of their disruptive anarchism, making them appear contained and controllable in a way that completely erodes their capacity to jolt the status quo out of its plateaus.
This becomes a democratic deficit and is a self-fulfilling process. For a public unable to effect real change by acting only as spectators means they will only ever be seen as such by those in power.
A reaction to how little was accomplished by the global antiwar marches against the invasion of Iraq in 2003 and the climate discussions that took place at COP15 last December, the film offers a sober and accurate criticism of “consume and spectate activism,” exuding an urgency to revive or evolve the art of protest.
If we are ever to escape the snare of ineffectual resistance, the art of protesting needs to break free from its current condition, which blocks almost all meaningful expression and participation and allows activist organizations to become as giant and as unanswerable as the states they seek to contest.
Food for thought.
Brain Pickings takes over 200 hours a month to curate, edit and publish. If you find joy and inspiration in it, please consider supporting us with a small donation — it lets us know we’re doing something right.
Psst, we’ve launched a fancy weekly newsletter. It comes out on Sundays, offers the week’s articles, and features five more tasty bites of web-wide interestingness. Here’s an example. Like? Sign up.
- Market Maketh Man: Distortions of Democracy An ambitious documentary critique of several models of liberal democratic doctrine, and an interview with the cunningly opinionated filmmaker....
- Social Media, News & The Democratic Process The news on news, or what Twitter has to do with democracy....
- Social Justice with a Twist: Ctrl.Alt.Shift A UK-based social initiative, Ctrl.Alt.Shift is a formally incorporated social movement for global justice, with an interesting departure from traditional anti-establishment associations....
- The Real Godfather: Il Divo The real Godfather, or what the Vatican has to do with assassination conspiracies....
- Spotlight Series: Gimme Moore Why P2P file-sharing can spell the demise of the Bush administration and how not to let American Idol trump the White House....
The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1aluE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1aluE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1aluE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1aluE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1aluE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The Art of Protest – insightful minidoc on toothless state of activism http://ow.ly/1aluE by @brainpicker (echo in flash Haiti fundraising?)
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1aluE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @TrackerNews The Art of Protest – activism as populist theatre http://ow.ly/1aluE by @brainpicker
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The Art of Protest is an excellent insight into today’s activism via @brainpicker http://ow.ly/1aluE
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: If you missed it: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1av13
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: The Art of Protest – insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1av13
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1av13
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The Art of Protesting: http://ow.ly/1av13 “Activist organizations have become as giant and unanswerable as the states they seek 2 contest.”
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: If you missed it: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1av13
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: If you missed it: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1av13
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The Art of Protest A very sad assessment of the modern protest movement. Today they have no teeth. Watch this. http://bit.ly/drY80e
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @brainpicker: The Art of Protest – cunning, insightful minidocumentary about the toothless state of today’s activism http://ow.ly/1av13
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The Art of Protest | Brain Pickings http://ow.ly/1b775
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
Art of Protest is v powerful short film on why modern protest doesnt work @HallyMk1 @josswinn @jamiepotter http://icio.us/a4vayg
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
why modernity breeds toothless anarchy http://icio.us/a4vayg [via @WarrenPearce]
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
RT @HallyMk1: why modernity breeds toothless anarchy http://icio.us/a4vayg [via @WarrenPearce]
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
shoutout on my site , fyi
heart!
Is the art of protest loosing its edge? http://bit.ly/dA1qgp via @brainpicker
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
The Art of Protest http://tinyurl.com/y8ga864
This comment was originally posted on Twitter
[...] may recall filmmaker Temujin Doran from The Art of Protest, a cunning short documentary about the democratic deficits of today’s political protests. [...]